Week 2: What future are we creating?
Week 2:
Task 1:
Journal Task 1:
Le Corbusier
Calypso
Mata Aho
China Town
James & Emma
Calypso
Mata Aho
China Town
James & Emma
Journal Task 2:
Identify at least four
of these and reflect on how they used to inform the development process product
(e.g. how one way of gathering information leads to another and then another).
Option A:
Haiyan Zhang gathered
information in several ways that obviously stood out to me in watching the
episode. Before Haiyan commenced any work on the project she met with Emma face
to face to develop a personal relationship and genuine understanding of the condition.
In doing this I recognised the similarity between her actions and following the
Kaupapa Maori guidelines; establishing a relationship and understanding before
any action is taken, this ensured that all Haiyan’s decisions from the
beginning of her work were focused around Emma’s needs.
From having a
conversation with Emma Haiyan was able to progress her project in an efficient
way; angling her research with a focus on what would be beneficial to Emma’s
desires and requirements. One medium of research used was a meeting with an
Oxford professor.
Haiyan re-collaborated
with Emma to explore if the concepts she had designed had any potential,
through a trial and error exercise to see how Emma personally felt using each
of the products and if she felt like they helped or hindered her in anyway.
This again refines Haiyan’s knowledge to Emma’s personal taste and what she
wants to get out of this collaboration. From this trial and error exercise
where Haiyan learnt more about the logistics of what works and doesn’t for
Emma’s specific condition she continued to research and although the clip
doesn’t give details on the type of research Haiyan used to discover the
counter-active vibrating spoon this is what inspired her final product.
Having found this
concept with precedential success Haiyan adapted it to be able to be effective
for the use of pens which was Emma’s desire. Having chosen a product she saw
potential in Haiyan took it to a focus group where she trialled it on other
people with Parkinson’s disease, working collaboratively and actively to get
feedback from each of them individually to see how they felt about the product
and if they had any doubts, concerns or suggestions. This feedback ensured that
what Haiyan felt was appropriate for this product was actually relevant to the
community she is designing it for.
Once Haiyan had
progressed through these developmental stages and collaborated with many minds
to ensure she was on the right track, she bought her product to Emma to trial.
However in doing so Haiyan was still open to the concept that it might not be
perfect for Emma and developed ways that Emma can make it work for herself
(through the app), so Haiyan did not create a “one size fits all” she gave Emma
the power to perfect the vibration strength and pattern in a way that works for
her an an individual.
Task 2:
Journal Task 3:
Kaupapa Maori
|
Massey Ethics
|
Written
academically however uses words that are warmer and more familiar. With
discussion on intangible things such as how people will feel-not just the end
result.
Feels like framework for the construction of
a safe space to collaborate in. Less rigid formalities.
3. Focus:
More on the process, and relationships established between all
involved.
4. Participation:
The involvement seems more equal. For example: this is what we want to
achieve, this is what we are thinking, what do YOU think about this, how
would YOU like to progress this research.
|
1. Language:
Written academically to a point it seems formal and distant. A lot of
use of negative words e.g. “burden”, “avoid”, “harm”.
2.
Feels
like more of a “what to do when things go wrong”, than guidelines for
constructive collaboration. Also seems to be a document to clarify the
liability and who’s at fault in a given situation.
3.
Focus:
On the product
4.
Participation:
The conductors have a fully designed project already and participants
either participate to the full extent or don’t, there is minimal space for
adaptability. Less collaborative.
|
Journal Task 4:
Le Corbusier's Ville Radieuse
– Kaupapa Maori Ethics:
Ville Radieuse has a
significant amount of inconsistencies with following th Kaupapa Maori ethical
guidelines. In Le Corbusier’s development process there was effectively no
coordination with the following of Whanaungatanga, which Haiyan based
essentially her entire project on. There appears to be no correlation between
his design process and any of the Kaupapa Maori ethical guidelines as Le
Corbusier did not meet with any one in the community he was designing this
project for, this makes it virtually impossible to follow manaakitanga, mahaki,
aroha, titiro and especially he kanohi kitea. The lack of communication in this
project makes it seem impossible to be successful as this is essentially him
projecting what he as an individual thinks is the best for this community. This
raises several questions; How would you preserve and sense of
culture/individuality? It would be interesting to know however if there were
people who desired to live in such a community what it was that drew them to
the idea. To me this project loses all sense of humanity and community which is
one of if not the primary focus of the kaupapa maori guidelines.
Le Corbusier’s Ville
Radieuse – Massey Universal Principles
Ville Radieuse follows
“Autonomy” in that the community Le Corbusier designed is optional
participation, you do not physically have to move in there that decision is
made on your own autonomy.
It is not clear if Le
Corbusier’s design follows the “avoidance of harm” ethical guideline as there seems
to be many dependent factors depending on intentions of those in authority.
This statement in the massey guidelines says that someones dignity and
relationships should not be harmed to. This raises the question of where the
line is and how could Le Corbusier be held responsible for any of the
individuals psychological harm that may be caused?
Justice is
demonstrated in the design as the design definitively involves a “fair
distribution” as this is essentially the basis of his whole design.
Ville Radiuese seems
to be significantly more cohesive with the Massey Guidelines than the Kaupapa
Maori ones.
Comments
Post a Comment